After over a month of hearings and five previous adjournments, the final verdict on Writ Petition 122/2017 was declared by the Supreme Court in favour of the petitioners on Thursday, April 13. In doing so, the apex court gave the green signal to include Urdu as one of the languages in which the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) will be held. However, as was expected since the initial hearing on the case took place, the addition of Urdu will only be applicable from the 2018-19 session onwards. A three member Bench led by Justice Dipak Misra and comprising Justices AM Khanwilkar and MM Shantanagoudar, directed the Centre and the CBSE to accede to the request of the Students Islamic Organization of India (SIO), the petitioning body, to add Urdu to the list of the existing ten languages in which NEET is held.
- Find top ranked colleges where you can seek admission
- Find Best Branch for each of the colleges
- Get a comprehensive personalized report for complete analysis
As reported by Careers360 on April 6, the chances of the SIO getting Urdu approved as a language for NEET 2017 were always slim, what with less than a month remaining for the exam scheduled to be held on May 7. However, it is likely to be a decision which appeases the petitioners, who had earlier even filed an affidavit accusing the Government of being communal by excluding Urdu from the list of NEET languages. As per the affidavit which was filed on March 30, the SIO claimed that it “deliberate and intentional on the part of the Health Ministry of the Government of India to not include Urdu as a medium for the NEET exam because of the discriminatory perception of the government functionaries in viewing the language as not a part of cultural heritage and composite culture of India...As the language is associated with Muslim religion...the government functionaries are prejudiced and biased and have deliberately excluded the Urdu language as medium for the NEET exams". These allegations had been refuted by Solicitor General Ranjit Kumar, appearing on behalf of the Centre and the CBSE, who from the first hearing onwards had maintained the stance that Urdu would be a welcome addition in NEET but only from next year onwards.
It is interesting to note that this decision, which will bring relief to thousands of aspirants who can appear for NEET in Urdu from next year, was one of two NEET related verdicts passed in favour of petitioning students by Justices Misra and Khanwilkar in the past two weeks. The same judges were earlier involved in removing the controversial upper age limit criteria for NEET 2017. The verdict was passed by them on March 31, thereby allowing students above the age of 25 to apply for NEET 2017. This was also only their second hearing in the NEET Urdu case, the first coming on April 10, after the original Bench of Justices Kurian Joseph and R Banumathi, having adjourned the verdict on four previous occasions, transferred the case to them on the same day the NEET age limit verdict was declared.
The counsel for the SIO had earlier requested the Bench to issue a direction for holding NEET 2017 in Urdu language or to direct the CBSE to hold a supplementary examination. As per media sources, in response to the SIO requesting for Urdu to be included from NEET 2017 itself, the Bench replied that it was impossible because of paucity of time. As per the Bench, “...the whole problem is that (holding NEET in Urdu) this year it is not possible…There are lots of difficulties. Please try to understand that we can’t ask the Centre to do miracles. The examination is on 7 May and today is 13 April. Lots of processes are involved in this...”. The counsel appearing for the CBSE and the MCI also disagreed with the reasoning behind holding a supplementary exam, arguing that "if the examination is held by way of a supplementary examination, it has the potentiality to dilute the NEET examination".
“We direct the Union of India to include Urdu as a language in NEET examination from academic session 2018-19 onwards”, the Bench declared, finally passing the verdict in favour of Urdu inclusion and bringing to an end the latest legal saga involving the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test.
Read below the entire timeline of the case.
Urdu in NEET: Timeline of events
Government of Maharashtra urges Centre to add Urdu to the list of NEET languages. “168 Urdu medium science junior colleges are running in the state, accounting for around 11,000 students appearing for class XII exam every year...Considering the large number of students from Urdu-medium appearing in NEET, it is necessary that the test be conducted in Urdu language too. We request the government to make appropriate changes to the present rules,” Girish Dattatray Mahajan, the Maharashtra State Minister of Medical Education is quoted saying.
CBSE releases notification stating NEET 2017 will be held in eight regional languages apart from Hindi and English. Oriya and Kannada are newly added but no Urdu.
Writ Petition 122/2017 filed by Students Islamic Organization of India (SIO) demanding for the inclusion of Urdu in NEET 2017. Petition argues that Urdu, being the sixth most spoken language in the country, deserves to be in the list as there will will more aspirants opting for it when compared to Gujarati, Assamese, Oriya and Kannada. The non-inclusion of Urdu in the list of NEET languages is a violation of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution, the SIO petition reads.
With NEET Application Window closing on March 1, SIO files a plea of urgency motion seeking for advancement of hearing date on inclusion of Urdu in NEET. A three member Bench, comprising Chief Justice of India, JS Khehar, and Justices DY Chandrachud and SK Kaul refuse to advance the hearing date, listing the first hearing for March 3.
NEET Application Window closes.
Two member SC Bench comprising Justices Kurian Joseph and R Banumathi hold first hearing, and issue notices to the Union Government, the Medical Council of India (MCI), the Dental Council of India (DCI) and the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) asking for their response with regard to why Urdu has not been included in the list of languages for NEET 2017.
The Centre informs SC that it is open to including Urdu as one of the languages in which NEET is held, but only from next year onwards and not for NEET 2017. Justices Joseph and Banumathi grant permission to the Centre and other bodies to submit full response by March 22; adjourn next hearing for March 24.
Court adjourns hearing to March 31; Counsel for SIO complains that matter continues to be delayed because Centre refuses to inform them in advance about the responses it files with the Court before each hearing.
SIO accuses Government of being communal, files affidavit alleging that it is “deliberate and intentional on the part of the Health Ministry of the Government of India to not include Urdu as a medium for the NEET exam because of the discriminatory perception of the government functionaries in viewing the language as not a part of cultural heritage and composite culture of India...As the language is associated with Muslim religion...the government functionaries are prejudiced and biased and have deliberately excluded the Urdu language as medium for the NEET exams".
Solicitor General Ranjit Kumar, appearing on behalf of the Centre, CBSE, MCI and DCI, requests for three days’ time from the Court to respond to the allegations in the SIO’s affidavit. Justices Joseph and Banumathi are also informed hearing on the NEET age limit case taking place on the same date before Justices Dipak Misra and AM Khanwilkar in Court No. 2 of the Supreme Court, who have re-opened NEET application window till April 5. While adjourning the next hearing to April 10, Justices Joseph and Banumathi state that it would be appropriate if the same Bench hears the NEET Urdu case as well.
NEET Application Window closes for second time.
New three member Bench of Justices Dipak Misra, AM Khanwilkar and MM Shantanagoudar adjourn date of verdict to April 13.
Inclusion of Urdu in NEET approved by SC from academic year 2018-19 onwards
Stay updated with the latest news on NEET at www.medicine.careers360.com!